7 Reasons Why You Must Visit the Finger Lakes in New York

Sharing is caring!

This is our love story. It starts in the New York Finger Lakes region. I’m guessing that you probably didn’t know: There are eleven Finger Lakes centrally located in the State of New York. Keuka Lake is ours. Thirty years ago, we gave our hearts to each other, and Keuka Lake stole them both. There are many reasons why you must visit the Finger Lakes in New York now. In this post I will tell you just seven.

Falling in Love in the Finger Lakes.

Our love affair began when our matchmaking best friend, Bebette, introduced us to each other. It was our third year of law school. But, Bebette refused to stop there. Instead, she stayed on us, relentlessly I might add, until we were a couple!

We first visited Bebette’s home on Keuka Lake together for our law school graduation party in May of 1989. It was a burn it down kind of party that we still talk about today! The rest, as they say, is history.

That summer, with a sprawling view of the lake in front of us, I said, “I love you” to Pat for the first time sitting on the front porch of Bebette’s parent’s lake home. We were drinking beer and eating peanuts. I think Pat may have choked and said, “I love peanuts.”

1. The Finger Lakes Are What Dreams Are Made Of.

During the many summers we spent on Keuka Lake, we developed “Flag Holiday” traditions surrounding Memorial Day, Fourth of July, and Labor Day. We spent lazy days on the water, boating, skiing, floating and swimming. (The water sport options were much more limited back then.) In the evenings, dining al fresco under the stars, we lingered at the dinner table with family and friends. We laughed, played games and told stories at beach bonfires.

We enjoyed long boat rides, hanging close along the shore. Pointing to tiny ramshackle cottages, we would say:  “We’re going to buy that one some day.”  Then we would laugh. We never really dreamed it would come true.

Then, it did!  Just a few years ago, we had the courage to chase our dream. It was unexpected, a leap of faith, a gamble. Somehow, with the help of Bebette, it all came together.

We love to travel and explore the world. Perhaps even more, we love coming home to Keuka Lake. Here are six more reasons why we love the region and why you should visit the Finger Lakes now.

2. The Finger Lakes in New York are Still an “Under the Radar” Destination.

Odds are that you have never heard of the New York Finger Lakes. And, that just may be the number one reason why you should visit!

Essential Facts About the Finger Lakes:

• The Finger Lakes are centrally located in New York State within the area between Rochester at the West, Elmira-Corning at the South, and Syracuse at the East.
• There are 11 Finger Lakes. They are: Canadice, Canandaigua, Cayuga, Conesus, Hemlock, Honeoye, Keuka, Otisco, Owasco, Seneca, and Skaneateles. All, except Keuka Lake, are long and narrow and shaped like fingers. Keuka Lake is the only Finger Lake shaped like a Y, similar to Lake Como in Italy.
• There are over 1000 waterfalls to explore in the Finger Lakes region of New York.
• Each lake has its own unique vibe, ranging from rustic nature refuge to upscale resort area.
• The Finger Lakes are an easy drive from any of the major Upstate New York cities and only about four and a half hours from New York City.
• Every season is beautiful on the Finger Lakes. In each season, there are opportunities for a outdoor activities, enjoying world class food and wine, and simply relaxing in the the tranquility of the region.

Freshwater blue-green glacial lakes, waterfalls, gorges and vineyards are bountiful throughout the area. Yet, the Finger Lakes remain unspoiled, uncrowded, and for the most part, undiscovered as a travel destination. The Finger Lakes are not overcome by tourism. Your visit is guaranteed to be relaxed and uncomplicated. Your perfect spot awaits.

But, the word is out! The Finger Lakes region was recently named as one of Bloomberg’s top 24 travel destinations to visit in 2020. There is no better time to visit our dazzling and charming Finger Lakes region.

3. Visit the Finger Lakes in Upstate New York for an Experience that is A World Apart from New York City.

When people think of New York, the first image that often comes to mind is the Big Apple, Manhattan. NYC is one of our favorite places to visit. Undeniably, the frenetic energy of the City that never sleeps is exhilarating. The Finger Lakes, at the opposite end of the spectrum, are equally intoxicating.

Close your eyes. Imagine driving leisurely along winding and rolling country roads. You pass lush green cow pastures, and the road takes you along crystal clear blue-green lakes, up and down rolling hills, and by verdant vineyards. Then, you find yourself in the middle of the perfect little Americana town. That is the New York Finger Lakes region!

Manhanattanites and Upstate New Yorkers may as well be from different sides of the ocean. To native “New Yorkers,” anything north of the Bronx is “Upstate.” Located approximately 250 miles from New York City, the Finger Lakes are way upstate. The truth is, New Yorkers think we are all a bunch of farmers. We think the joke is on them!

Our daily work lives are hectic. The pace is slower and the days just a bit longer at the lake. Life is simpler.

The hardest thing about visiting the Finger Lakes is deciding the type of experience you prefer. Do you favor an uncomplicated and quiet stay in the country, the sweet Americana charm of a weekend in a quaint village, the pampering of a world class spa, a five-star food and wine experience, or the understated indulgence of a lake side cottage? Whatever adventure you choose, one thing is certain. You will not visit the New York Finger Lakes without falling hopelessly in love.

Find more information about where to stay, what to do, and trip planning tools on the web at: Yates County Chamber of Commerce, Visit Ithaca, Canandaigua Chamber of Commerce, and Skaneateles Chamber of Commerce. You will find additional information at the Finger Lakes Tourism Alliance, Visit Finger Lakes, and Finger Lakes Regional Tourism Council.

4. Drive to Visit the Finger Lakes in New York to Drink in the Gorgeous Countryside.

Still, after thirty years, when I hop into my car to make the ninety-mile drive from where we work in Syracuse, New York, to our lake home, my heart starts beating a little faster. I feel a smile creep onto my face. It is as if someone has let me out of a cage and set me free outdoors.

The Finger Lakes are an easy drive from any of the major Upstate New York cities (Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse and Albany), and only about four and a half hours from New York City. No matter where you begin, the drive to any one of the eleven Finger Lakes will take you along country roads, through quaint and charismatic small towns and past farms, antique shops, hometown diners, farm markets, flower and produce stands and vineyards.

The country roads in the Finger Lakes are long and winding, and rolling up and down hills. Often there are no other vehicles for miles. In the summer, lush green grass and fields of corn line the roads. Neat rows of grapevines in the vineyards tumble gently down hill.

Every Season in the Finger Lakes is Gorgeous.

In the fall, green meadows fade into golden corn fields against the back drop of fiery foliage, leaves of gold, orange and red. The drive in winter is like traveling through a desert lightly dusted with white snow. White flakes swirl around the faded gold and brown farmland and vineyards. Barns, fields, and trees sparkle in the sun light. As spring erupts, the grassy fields turn a bright yellow-green, the apple orchards burst with white blooms, and baby chicks peep around farmyards near the new born shaky-legged calves.

I don’t always love to drive distances. But, I love driving in the Finger Lakes. I can feel the stress melt away as I exit the New York Thruway and start my venture down the country roads. A relaxed drive to the Finger Lakes is the perfect way to whet your appetite for the tranquil feast for the body and soul you will experience when you visit the Finger Lakes.

5. Visit the Finger Lakes for the lakes, of course!

Without question, what we love most about our region is our lake. There is nothing better than lounging on our dock, a cold drink in hand, soaking in the vibrant or sometimes muted colors of the wildly romantic sunsets, or taking a relaxed booze cruise at sunset on a quiet Sunday night.

Each of the 11 Finger Lakes has a different personality. The region is ideal for kayaking, hiking, biking, boating and just chilling. If you talk to someone who is familiar with the area, there is no doubt she will gush about her favorite lake. In this post, I will highlight only some features about a few of the lakes. Look for more in depth information about each of the lakes in future posts!

Canadice Lake is the Nature Lover’s Paradise.

The smallest lake, Canadice, is just three miles long and .3 miles wide. There is no development on the shoreline of Canadice Lake. In fact, development along the shore is prohibited. It is pure unspoiled nature. Swimming is not permitted. Boats are restricted to seventeen feet in length and ten horsepower motors. Canadice Lake is surrounded by the Hemlock-Canadice State Forest, which covers 6,684 acres. This Finger Lake is a haven for nature lovers and fishermen. Grab a kayak and paddle in peace!

It’s all Fun, Funky and Waterfalls on Cayuga Lake.

Cayuga Lake is the longest lake, at approximately 40 miles long. At the south end of Cayuga Lake lies the City of Ithaca, New York, home to Cornell University as well as Ithaca College. An artsy, hippie-ish college town, Ithaca is a small hub of art, culture, diversity and nature.

We’ve caught some excellent live musical performances at small venues in Ithaca. The Haunt is an iconic and classic spot for live shows.

Unique among the towns in the Finger Lakes, in the middle of downtown Ithaca there is a four-block area closed to vehicular traffic called “Ithaca Commons.” There you will find an eclectic mix of shops and restaurants, public art displays, and street performers.

The City of Ithaca on Cayuga Lake is Gorges!

Ithaca’s slogan is, “Ithaca is Gorges.” In a ten-mile area, there are over 150 waterfalls Glaciers carved out these gorges millions of years ago. Robert H. Treman State Park is one of the parks located located within the City of Ithaca. A winding and rugged gorge trail runs through the park and past 12 waterfalls. The largest waterfall is 115 feet tall! Check out some of Ithaca’s waterfalls here.

Visit Canandaigua Lake for a Buzz of Activity.

Canandaigua Lake buzzes with activity, especially in the summer. These boathouses at City Pier remind me of a New England fishing town. They were built in 1853 and are still used today. In the 1800’s the boathouses were owned by people who couldn’t afford lake houses. The boathouses are built on “finger piers” jutting out into the water. The area is alluring and photogenic. It is a favorite subject of amateur and professional photographers alike. Along the piers there are a few shops and restaurants. Directly across from the piers is a public park, Kershaw, with a public beach and access point to the lake.

You Will Be Enthralled by Extravagances in Canandaigua.

Canandaigua has been called the unofficial “welcome mat” of the Finger Lakes Wine Country. Just off of Main Street in Canandaigua, New York and only steps from the lake, New York Kitchen offers a unique experience for foodies, including local food and wine pairings and classes. The mission of New York Kitchen is to educate and immerse visitors in the craft beverage, culinary and agriculture bounty of the region.

Canandaigua Lake is one of the more upscale Finger Lakes. I grew up in a middle class family. My well-off friend had fancy old farmhouse right on Canandaigua Lake where her family summered. It was a special treat if I was invited to visit. What kid doesn’t love the feeling of running down a dock and jumping into a lake? In those days, we used tire inner tubes to float in the water. We would spending the whole day lounging in our black rubber tubes, laughing in the lake.

What I though was fancy 40 years ago pales in comparison to what you will find on Canandaigua Lake today. Extravagant homes, condos and marinas line the shores of this lake. Bloomberg reports that the high end architects and designers at Studio Tack will soon open Lake House on Canandaigua Lake, which will include a spa and timber -framed event barn.

Skaneateles is Another Place to Go for an Upscale Experience.

Arguably, the prettiest little town in the Finger Lakes is the historic Village of Skaneateles. That is also the name of its lake. The upscale village has much to experience year round. I love to visit Skaneateles, but in the end it is a little too frou-frou for me. I prefer to be on the more laid back Keuka.

Skaneateles is a Charming Village, Steeped in History, With Sweeping Lake Views.

In the center of the Village of Skaneateles is the classic and popular Sherwood Inn and Restaurant, built as a stage coach stop in 1807, and operating today year round. In the lakefront park across the street you can take in scenic views of Skaneateles Lake, one of the purest lakes in the country. Hop on an old-fashioned dinner boat and cruise around the lake. Look for fun festivals and a farmers market throughout the year. After Thanksgiving through Christmas, the Village becomes the charming storybook Dickens Village with live characters, performances, music and special events.

If You Prefer Posh, Opt for Skaneateles.

For a posh and pampering experience, there’s Mirbeau Inn and Spa in Skaneateles. Mirbeau has a long list of accolades, including being named on of the 100 best spas in North America by Conde Nast. I’ve been to many spas. I agree that Mirbeau ranks at the top. The pre-treatment relaxation room feels very old world, perhaps a bit like the ancient Roman baths. At minimum, you should plan to spend a full day at the spa.

The restaurant at Mirbeau is cozy in the cold weather. But, my favorite time to visit is in the summer. Sitting on the terrace overlooking the garden, it feels like you are sitting in the middle of a Monet painting.

It’s hard not to love idyllic Skaneateles.

Visit Seneca Lake for Trout fishing, Nascar and Chasing Waterfalls.

Seneca Lake is nearly as long as Cayuga Lake and is the deepest of the Finger Lakes. The deepest points of Seneca are 618 feet! Fisherman love the trout, Atlantic salmon, small mouth bass, yellow perch, and other fish swimming in the cold and deep Seneca Lake waters.

Seneca Lake is flanked by two lovely towns. At the North end of Seneca Lake is Geneva. Geneva is home to Hobart & William Smith Colleges. Geneva has a distinctly college-town, trendy vibe.

World Class Dining Awaits in Geneva, New York.

In Geneva you can experience world class dining. F.L.X. Table , an intimate 14-seat venue, receives rave reviews. The restaurant was recently named one of the best in the United States! You must book online a month in advance when the reservations open at the beginning of the month. It’s like the lottery. It seems like pure luck if you can snag a spot. We haven’t yet won one.

Watkins Glen is Edgy and Exciting.

At the opposite end of Seneca Lake lies Watkins Glen, anchoring Seneca Lake at the south. Watkins Glen is famous for its exciting NASCAR racing, Watkins Glen International.

• 

Gorges and Waterfalls Await in Watkins Glen State Park.

Another highlight is Watkins Glen State Park. Hiking the Gorge Trail at Watkins State Park is one of my favorite things to do in the area. There are 19 waterfalls along the stone path of this trail. The 1.5 mile path winds under and over the waterfalls and through stone carved tunnels. Get there early though, because the park attracts thousand of visitors each year. It’s so much more fun (and peaceful), when it seems like you’re the only one there.

Keuka Lake Is Unique Among the Finger Lakes

Keuka is different from the rest. It is the only lake that is shaped like a “Y.” At 800 feet above sea level, the views from Keuka’s bluff are incredible.

Keuka Lake is a popular destination for scenic drives and cycling. To us, Keuka is the perfect blend of quiet country and understated, unpretentious lake luxury.

Penn Yan is Priceless.

Penn Yan, a classic little American town, is located at the north end of Keuka Lake. In Penn Yan, there is a unique mix of bars and homey restaurants. The Penn Yan Diner, for example, is a traditional old school Galion Dining Car style diner located on Elm Street. It originally opened in 1925. The venue is quite small. There are 5 tables and 10 counter stools. But, the menu is surprisingly varied including tasty and unique breakfast dishes.

The Keuka Outlet Trail Connects Keuka and Seneca Lakes.

Hiking or biking the Keuka Outlet Trail is an active adventure we enjoy year round. The 7-mile trail begins in Penn Yan near The Birkett Mills (which is world famous for buckwheat products). It spans from the top of Keuka Lake to the Town of Dresden on Seneca Lake. The trail is open to hikers, cyclists and horseback riders. There are several access points along the trail and two waterfalls along the way. Don’t miss Turtle Pond where the small turtles line up on fallen trees to sun themselves.

Hammondsport is Always Cool.

The Village of Hammondsport is at the south end of Keuka Lake. Hammondsport was voted “Coolest Small Town in America” by readers of Budget Travel. I love the character and calmness of this little town. In the middle of this delightful village restaurants, shops and antique stores are organized around a town square and veterans memorial park and gazebo.

It’s relaxing to enjoy a glass of wine and a snack sitting in the park, or at a sidewalk table of one of the restaurants and watch the low key bustle of activity.

There are several unique inns and bed and breakfasts in Hammondsport. In the summer and fall there a quiet hum of activity, day and night. But, Hammondsport never seems over crowded.

Throughout the year Hammondsport hosts several events, including an antique boat show and music in the park during the summer months. The lake shore is about a three block walk from the Village center.

Tour de Keuka , an event promoted by the Hammondsport Chamber of Commerce, is an annual charity bike ride that benefits the Food Bank of the Southern Tier. Cyclists participate in a 17, 45, 60 or a 100-mile ride to raise money to feed families struggling with hunger.

6. When Visiting the Finger Lakes You Must Drink Wine.

For the second year in a row, in 2019 the Finger Lakes region was named the best wine region in the United States by readers of USA Today In addition, Wine Enthusiast recently recognized the Finger Lakes as one of five “under the radar” wine regions to visit. There are more than 120 wineries in the area. Many of them have been recognized for outstanding wines. The area is best known for producing excellent Rieslings. Red wines produced in this region, however, are also now gaining notoriety.

Each of the wineries has its own vibe, ranging the gamut — from rustic old barn, to industrial, to romantic chateau.

Winemakers from around the world are making wine in the Finger Lakes. At some of the wineries, it feels like you have been transported to Sonoma, or even to Italy. At many of the wineries, there are sweeping views of the rolling hills and lakes.

Here you will find mapped wine trails on Canandaigua, Cayuga, Keuka and Seneca Lakes, where the majority of the wineries are located. You can also find more information at the Finger Lakes Tourism Alliance. It’s easy to book a winery tour. Or, it’s even more fun to strike out on your own and wander leisurely along the country roads and lakes from winery to winery.

7. Newer to the Region Are Microbreweries and Distilleries That You Must Also Visit.

But, don’t stop there! More recently, breweries and distilleries have popped up throughout the region and are gaining popularity. Like the wineries, many host live music and serve local and/or seasonal fare. In the summer, these venues often host food trucks on site and a festive atmosphere. Check out the Finger Lakes Beer Trail website for a map of participating breweries and events.

There is a listing of some of the microbreweries and distilleries on the Finger Lakes Wine Country website. Regional distilleries offer tastings of distilled vodka, whiskey, brandy and liqueurs made from locally grown produce. Like the wineries and breweries in the region, the distilleries frequently host entertainment and food specialties to complement your tasting experience.

The Love Affair Continues …

Thirty years later, our love affair continues exactly where it began. The lake is magnetic and at times downright dreamy. Our hearts skip with excitement at first glimpse of the lake when we arrive. Sadness still sets in every single time we depart. When I wake in the morning, I rush to the front windows to sneak a peak at the water. It reminds of the mood rings that were popular in the 1970’s, except that my mood ring was always black.

The color of the lake changes throughout the day and throughout the seasons. It can be bright blue, emerald green, silvery, black-gold. The variations seem endless.

We fell for this mesmerizing place at the same time we fell for each other. And, to this day, there is no place we would rather be than hanging out alone, together on Keuka Lake. You really should visit.